What separates a great deal from a mediocre one
By Suraj Bhakta
Every investor at every conference is reciting the same thesis: Resilient demand, favorable demographics, a category built for the moment. The fundamentals are real, but when an entire asset class reaches consensus, it stops being an edge. The nuances that separate a strong extended stay investment from a mediocre one are getting papered over by category enthusiasm, and that’s exactly where the biggest strategic advantages lie.
Not Every Market is Right
The most important thing to get right is demand – it is the core indicator of whether an extended stay asset will perform the way the model requires. Healthcare facilities, energy projects, government contracts, and large-scale construction are examples of the specific demand that produces long, 30-to60-day stays.
A market built on leisure travel or seasonal tourism is a poor fit almost by definition. There is no reason for those guests to stay for an extended stretch. The demand type must match the product type, and that alignment starts with understanding what’s driving the local economy.
Secondary and supply-constrained markets are often the better bet here. Primary markets like Phoenix, Dallas, and Nashville carry land costs that are increasingly hard to pencil for a product category that runs on specific margins. Secondary markets offer lower entry costs and, in many cases, the same structural demand generators – a regional hospital, a multi-year infrastructure project, a government installation – without the competition that follows in gateway cities.
Taking the Accurate Approach
One of the most consistent mistakes being made right now is applying traditional hotel metrics to extended stay underwriting. Looking at what the comp set is doing on ADR and RevPAR matters, but it’s not enough – in some cases, it’s actively misleading.
Multifamily vacancy should be part of your analysis. Extended stay competes with apartments and short-term rentals in ways that a standard select-service hotel does not. If a multifamily owner in the same market decides to pivot toward short-term rentals, they can undercut an extended stay hotel on price and flexibility. Ignoring that supply side is a blind spot.
The physical product matters, too. Slapping a kitchenette label on a room doesn’t make it an extended stay. A microwave and a mini fridge don’t create the operational environment that keeps guests for 30 or 60 days. The product has to be functional, or guests simply won’t treat it like one.
Building the Occupancy Floor
The extended stay model works when you build a reliable baseline of long-duration guests and then optimize the remaining inventory. Think about a property where 65 percent of rooms are consistently occupied by 30-to-60-day residents. That’s your floor. It’s predictable, stable, and doesn’t swing with the seasons.
The revenue management opportunity lives in that remaining 15 to 20 percent of vacancy. Once the baseline is set, that’s where the extra yield gets captured. But you can’t reverse engineer it; you need the long-stay foundation first. A property that’s chasing transient demand to fill gaps has a fundamentally different cost and revenue structure than one that’s built around a stable occupancy core.
This is also why seasonality is such an important warning sign. An extended stay running 85 percent in summer and 40 percent in winter isn’t operating as an extended stay. It’s operating as a leisure hotel with bigger rooms.
To Be or Not to Be
The decision to flag an extended stay property or run it independently comes down to one thing: Where your guests are coming from. If you’re competing for corporate travel managers who are booking through channels, insurance companies with preferred vendor lists, or healthcare staffing firms with negotiated rates, a brand buys you real distribution value. The flag earns its fee.
But if the bulk of your occupancy is coming from direct relationships such as pre-negotiated corporate accounts, government per diem contracts, or a handful of large employers or agencies that reliably fill your rooms, a brand might add cost without adding value.
The mistake is treating the brand decision as a signal of quality or commitment to the asset. Rather, it comes down to a math question. Does the distribution the flag provides solve a problem? If yes, pay for it. If your demand is already contractual and direct, you’re effectively paying for someone else’s brand equity.
Where the Real Opportunity Is
The cost to build from scratch today is steep in most markets, which means buying a struggling select service hotel or an underperforming apartment building and converting it to extended stay can offer a basis that ground-up construction simply can’t match. The bones often work: Room counts, parking, the location relative to employment corridors. What changes is the operational model and, in some cases, the physical product.
Secondary markets with genuine structural demand generators are also underappreciated. Costs of entry are lower, competition is thinner, and if the demand profile is anchored in healthcare, energy, or government work, this option can be more durable than markets riding a demographic wave or a leisure trend.
Asking the Right Questions
Extended stay will keep attracting capital because the macro story is compelling and the operating model holds up. But the investors who outperform will be the ones who asked better questions before they bought the deal.
Ask yourself: Is the demand structural or cyclical? Is the occupancy floor built on longterm guests or propped up by transient fill? Is the physical product functional for a 45day stay, or is it a hotel room with a microwave? What is multifamily vacancy doing in that market? Does a brand solve a real distribution problem?
The category doesn’t guarantee the return. The market, the demand mix, the basis, and the operational discipline do.
Suraj Bhakta is CEO of NewGen Advisory, a full service commercial real estate brokerage firm specializing in hospitality and lodging assets and a Silver Industry Partner. He also serves as chief legal officer of NewGen Worldwide.
Image: BillionPhotos.com/stock.adobe.com
Leave a Reply